Long Term Cost Benefits of Invisible Retainers Compared to Traditional Options

For many individuals, an orthodontic treatment plan is a key step in achieving a confident smile and optimal oral health. Once the braces come off or the aligners have done their job, the next step is usually to fit a retainer to ensure long-term success. Among the various retainer options available, invisible dental retainers have gained popularity due to their discreet nature. Here we consider the advantages of invisible dental retainers compared to other options, along with their economic benefits.

Traditional Retainers vs. Invisible Retainers

Until recently, retainers have mainly come in two types: removable Hawley retainers and fixed/permanent retainers, known as lingual or bonded retainers or lingual wires. Hawley retainers, usually consisting of an acrylic plate and metal retaining wires, have been the standard choice of removable retainer for many years. Removable retainers are popular among patients who prefer not to have a fixed retainer following active treatment. 

Although Hawley retainers are effective, they come with some drawbacks, including the visibility of the wire and potentially lower levels of comfort. Invisible dental retainers, on the other hand, are crafted from clear plastic, making them virtually undetectable. This aesthetic advantage is a significant factor in their growing popularity.

One of the key considerations when evaluating the long-term cost benefits of dental retainers is the durability and longevity of the device. Hawley retainers can be prone to wear and tear, potentially leading to replacements and additional costs over time. Invisible retainers are made of thin plastic molded perfectly to fit the teeth, reducing the likelihood of damage.

Cost-Effective Maintenance

The care and maintenance of retainers is an important factor in long-term cost effectiveness. Fixed lingual retainers can be challenging to clean thoroughly, and orthodontists usually advise patients to brush and floss after every meal using specialist floss threaders. (1) This can add to the ongoing costs of fixed retainers, in addition to time spent on maintenance. 

Poor maintenance of a fixed retainer can lead to hygiene-related issues, including plaque buildup, cavities and gum disease, all of which can be costly to treat. In contrast, invisible dental retainers are easily removable, allowing for convenient cleaning. If patients use recommended products and follow their cleaning regimen, maintenance can be simple and affordable. 

Comparing invisible retainers to Hawley retainers, the simplicity of cleaning invisible dental retainers can translate to a lower likelihood of damage during the cleaning process. Hawley retainers may be more susceptible to breakage or deformation if mishandled during cleaning. This potential fragility can contribute to higher maintenance costs over time.

Aesthetic Considerations

The aesthetic appeal of invisible dental retainers extends beyond their nearly invisible appearance. Traditional retainers, with their metal components, can be a source of self-consciousness for many individuals, particularly adults. They can also affect speech, especially during the initial wear period. The discreet nature of invisible dental retainers allows users to maintain their orthodontic results without drawing attention to their dental appliances. This enhanced confidence can positively impact various aspects of life, from professional settings to social interactions.

While it may be challenging to quantify the economic value of enhanced self-esteem, studies suggest a strong correlation between self-confidence and overall well-being. Individuals who feel more confident are often more successful in their personal and professional lives, potentially leading to increased opportunities and financial benefits.

Customization and Comfort

Invisible dental retainers are custom made for each individual’s unique dental structure. This customization not only ensures a snug fit but also contributes to enhanced comfort. Hawley retainers, although effective, may cause some initial discomfort, leading to non-compliance and potentially compromising the stability of orthodontic results.

The comfort offered by invisible dental retainers promotes consistent usage, which is vital for maintaining the alignment achieved through orthodontic treatment. Inconsistent use of retainers can result in orthodontic relapse, which can require additional interventions and their associated costs. By investing in a retainer that prioritizes comfort and a personalized fit, individuals are more likely to adhere to their prescribed wear schedule, thereby avoiding the need for costly corrective measures.

Long-Term Stability and Cost Efficiency

The primary goal of wearing dental retainers is to preserve the results achieved through orthodontic treatment. Invisible dental retainers, with their custom fit and durability, excel in providing long-term stability. The reduced risk of relapse or the need for additional orthodontic procedures contributes to the overall cost efficiency of invisible retainers.

Long-term cost benefits of invisible dental retainers compared to other options make them a compelling choice for individuals seeking to maintain the results of their orthodontic treatment. The discreet nature, ease of maintenance, aesthetic considerations, customization, comfort, and long-term stability contribute to the overall economic value of invisible dental retainers. While the initial investment in invisible retainers may be slightly higher than some other options, the potential for low maintenance costs and improved compliance may make them the most cost-effective choice. (2)


1. https://www.premierdentalohio.com/blog/cleaning-and-maintaining-a-permanent-retainer 
2. https://www.healthline.com/health/retainer-types#comparison-chart